Dostoevsky Studies     Volume 7, 1986

Professional News

Sixième Symposium International Dostoïevski

Discours d'ouverture

Michel Cadot, Président de l'IDS

Mes chers collègues, mesdames, messieurs,

C'est un plaisir et un honneur pour moi d'ouvrir ce Vlème Symposium international Dostoïevski, organisé à Nottingham par notre collègue Malcolm Jones et son équipe. Je remercie madame le professeur Fell, prorecteur de l'Université, d'avoir bien voulu accueillir le Symposium: sa spécialité, l'étude des Vikings, n'est pas aussi éloignée qu'il le semble de notre champ habituel de réflexion, car on prétend que les Varègues, cousins des Vikings, furent appelés autrefois par les Slaves pour mettre de l'ordre dans leurs affaires. Je saisis l'occasion pour rappeler que j'eus l'honneur, il y a quatre ans, d'assister à un autre colloque, consacré à Herzen, et organisé en cette même Université par madame le professeur Monica Partridge, ce nui atteste le succès des études slaves à Nottingham.

Ce Vlème Symposium Dostoïevski marque le quinzième anniversaire de notre Société. Remarquable longévité pour une entreprise animée par la seule bonne volonté de ses membres, qui lui permettent de vivre par leurs cotisations et leur attachement désintéressé à l'oeuvre de F. M. Dostoïevski, un auteur qui n'était pas bien riche lui non plus. Les organisateurs de nos rencontres triennales savent qu'ils ne peuvent compter que sur leur habileté à obtenir des subventions de leurs universités, des autorités régionales, nationales ou internationales comme l'UNESCO dont l'aide est particulièrement précieuse.

Je salue ici les efforts de Nadine Natov et de Rudolf Neuhäuser, organisateurs du premier symposium à Bad Ems (1971), à mes yeux véritable mythe fondateur puisque en ces temps reculés je n'étais pas encore né en Dostoïevski, ceux du Dr. Dox, hélas disparu depuis, à St. Wolfgang (1974), ceux de Carl Stief à Rungstedgaard (1977), de Nina Kautchichvili à Bergame (1980), les miens à Cerisy-la-Salle (1983): il est en effet agréable de se décerner à soi-même des éloges, et last but not least, ceux de Malcolm Jones à Nottingham.

Plusieurs collègues éminents sont disparus depuis 1971, et je voudrais rappeler ici les noms de Dmitri Čiževskij, de Gleb Struve, de Jan Meijer, de Sigurd Fasting. D'autres n'ont pu venir à Nottingham pour des raisons variées, et nous regrettons profondément l'absence cette année de notre président d'honneur René Wellek dont nous avions fêté le 80ème anniversaire à Cerisy (mais heureusement Georgii Mikhailovitch Fridlender, également président d'honneur, est parmi nous cette fois!); parmi les absents de marque, citons encore Mme Dominique Arban, Åke Nilsson, Carl Stief, Jan Van der Eng, Nina

206

Kautchichvili, Reinhard Lauth, Konrad Onasch.

Au cours des trois années écoulées depuis le précédent Symposium, deux difficultés majeures ont dû être résolues par le Bureau exécutif de cette Société. La première fut la coincidence des dates retenues pour le Symposium de Nottingham et la rencontre des professeurs de russe dans le cadre du MAPRJAL à Budapest. Devant l'impossibilité de trouver un autre lieu et/ou une autre date pour le Symposium de l'I.D.S., j'ai dû, après bien des hésitations, maintenir notre réunion à Nottingham en 1986. Un autre problème, plus grave encore, a été le sauvetage in extremis de notre revue Dostoevsky Studies, que l'éditeur associé renonça brusquement à publier à l'Université de Tennessee. Grâce à la diligence de l'éditeur, Rudolf Neuhäuser, et aux efforts de Nadine Natov, la publication des numéros 5 et 6 put être assurée par les Universités de Klagenfurt et de Ljubljana. Des précisions sur la situation financière de la revue seront données à l'Assemblée générale.

La dernière question que je voudrais aborder avec vous ce soir est celle du prochain Symposium. Il aura lieu en 1989. Je ne puis vous dire encore où il se tiendra, car trois propositions ont déjà été avancées, l'une au sud-est de l'Europe, l'autre au nord et la troisième à l'est. Je retiendrai seulement comme un signe de vitalité encourageant pour notre Société que plusieurs propositions se trouvent en concurrence! En attendant que ce petit mystère soit éclairci, je remercie encore une fois Malcolm Jones et Richard Peace pour l'accueil chaleureux que nous recevons à Nottingham, et je suis sûr que ce Vlème Symposium consacré à F. M. Dostoïevski sera un grand succès!

Michel Cadot
 

Professor Christine Fell, Pro Vice-chancellor of the University of Nottingham, welcomed the Symposium on behalf of the University. Professor Malcolm Jones also welcomed the Symposium on behalf of the Organising Committee, the Department of Slavonic Studies at Nottingham and as President of the British Universities Association of Slavists. He recalled previous symposia and said what a pleasure and honour it was to be able to welcome participants to the VI Symposium at Nottingham.

207

Report

Rudolf Neuhäuser, Editor

The time between the last Symposium at Cerisy (1983) and the present meeting in Nottingham has been particulary dramatic because of Prof. Martin Rice's departure. In January 1984, after the decision had been taken concerning the contents of nos. 4 and 5 of "Dostoevsky Studies" Prof. Rice assured Prof. Natov that no. 4 would be printed early in April 1984. I kept writing to Prof. Rice, sending material and correspondence (requests by bookstores and libraries) to him. After not having received an answer I asked Prof. Natov to contact Prof. Rice. In early summer 1984 (May-June) it became obvious that there were problems and that Prof. Rice may not be able to complete no. 4. In a letter dated Sept. 9, 1984, Prof. Rice finally informed me that almost 90% of the final version of no. 4 had been erased on the computer due to a mistake. He made every effort to catch up spending $ 300 out of his own pocket for a typist (the Dept. paid $ 150 to a secretary for typing papers), but the work on the computer was done poorly: "There still remains two or three weeks of editing and printing of the final product in order to get the 1983 issue to the printer. It will be absolutely impossible for me to take this much time before January (1984) when I return to the University."

During Sept. and October 1984 I spent seven weeks on a lecture tour in Canada and could talk to Prof. Rice and his colleague Fiene trying to get Prof. Rice to complete, at least, no. 4. After my return, in a letter of Dec. 2, Prof. Rice informed me that he had resigned from university (effective March 1985) and was leaving the profession. As of this date (letter of Dec. 2, 1984) he forwarded all his material to me.

At the beginning of the new year (1985) it was clear that either we would have to discontinue the journal or find a new way of publishing it. The printing establishment used by the Slavic Dept. in Ljubljana offered reasonable prices, and I could persuade my university to pay for the mailing costs. Our departmental secretary would type some papers in German and English. The only problem were papers in Russian and French. Assistence was offered eventually by Professors Kaucisvili, Natov, Zohrab and Terras. With their help and the help of our secretary and two additional typists who had to be paid by IDS all the papers were typed by early March 1985. In April 1985 issues 4 and 5 were in print and were sent to subscribers. Problems arose when I charged the old price ($ 10,—) and Prof. Natov charged $ 12,— for no. 5 in line with a decision by NADS raising membership

208

fees in December 1984 to $ 12,—. This was applied to all IDS members and subscribers, - the editor was informed only late in April. After more problems which were all solved eventually, no. 6 was produced the same way and was mailed to subscribers in spring 1986.

A considerable problem was caused by the falling course of the dollar. Between 1984 and 1986 the dollar lost about a quarter of its exchange value. This may eventually force us to raise the subscription rate to $ 15.—. We have presently in Europe about 40 institutional subscribers and about 45 individual subscribers (members). Outside Europe we have a comparable member of subscribers. Altogether we need at least 150 paying subscribers to break even. I would like to appeal to you to see to it that your institution subscribes to "Dostoevsky Studies". I also appeal to all colleagues in countries where there is no currency problem to pay their annual fee. In particular, I wish to express my gratitude to Professor Donald Fiene of the University of Tennessee who has regularly supported the printing of the journal with a grant of $ 300 to 400 per issue!

An exact account of funds received and spent has been given to the Executive and has been checked by Prof. V. Terras. Altogether the printing of issues 4, 5 and 6 cost approximately $ 4,000.—, typing and mailing amounted to another $ 1,200.—

In the future, "Dostoevsky Studies" will be printed and bound in Ljubljana with the assistance of Prof. A. Skaza as technical editor. The journal will also be mailed out from Ljubljana. Fees should, however, be paid to the Secretary General, Professor Nadine Natov.

A special vote of gratitude is due to our collaborators in the bibliography section, Ms. Roberta W. Goldblatt, Molly Molloy and June Pachuta Farris. In place of Prof. Rice it will be Prof. J. Pachuta Farris who will be in charge of the Bibliography Section of "Dostoevsky Studies" in the future. Please address all bibliographical information to her at the Joseph Regenstein Library, The University of Chicago, 110O East 57th Street, Chicago, 1ll. 60637, U.S.A.

I would like to conclude this brief survey with an expression of my gratitude to all colleagues who have assisted in the editorial work. Your advice, and, above all, the products of your scholarly endeavours in the field of Dostoevsky studies, will always be welcome.

Nadine Natov: Report of the Secretary General
See p.215

209

At the end of the Symposium, Professor Malcolm Jones expressed his appreciation for the thanks which he had received and in his turn thanked Professor Richard Peace, Bristol, and Dr Cynthia Marsh, Dr James Muckle and Miss Joanne Davies, Nottingham, for their invaluable help. He also wished to express his gratitude to Dr Tony Briggs, Bristol, and Mr Bill Leatherbarrow, Sheffield, who had helped with the initial correspondence and Mr Ian Mair and his staff at Nightingale Hall for accommodation and meals. He said that when he had attended the first Symposium in Bad Ems, he had greatly valued the opportunity of meeting distinguished specialists from all over the world, and was even more glad to be able to welcome so many of them to his own University of Nottingham. Finally, he expressed his good wishes to Professor Aleksander Skaza and his colleagues at the University of Ljubljana for the organisation of the Seventh Symposium in Slovenia in 1989.

 

 

Редакция желает обратить внимание читателей на ниже воспроизведенную статью в "Литературной газете" от 12-го ноября 1986 г. на стр.2 и выражает надежду, что сотрудничество с учеными СССР и дальше будет развиваться благоуспешно.

 

ДОСТОЕВСКИЙ И СОВРЕМЕННОСТЬ
 

Недавно в Ноттингеме (Англия)  прошел VI симпозиум Международного обществa по изучению Достоевского (МОД), возникшего в 1971 году и отметившего в этом году пятнадцать летсвоего существования.  В  работе  общества принимаютучастие ученые 20 стран—таковразмах  всемирной славы великого русского писателя.  В симпозиуме участвовали  80 исследователей творчества Достоевского— в том числе из СССР, ПНР, ГДР,ВНР, СФРЮ, Великобритании, Франции, Бельгни, ФРГ, Италии, Японии, США, Канады, Австралии, Новой Зеландии, Индии.

МОД имеет двух пожизненно избранных почетных президентов — Г, М. Фридлендера (СССР) и Р. Уэллекa (США),известного специалиста по сравнительному  литературоведению, автора переведенной на русский язык и широко известной у нaс «Теории литературы» (нaписaнной совместно с О. Уорреном). На симпозиуме в Ноттингемeбыло единогласно принято решение просить академика  Д. С. Лихачeва стать такжe почетным президентом общeства. Выступавшие единодушно отмeчaлибольшие заслуги академика Лихачea, как и других советских ученых, в изучении Достоевского. При этом нaзывались труды М. Бахтина, А, Долининa, Л. Гроссмана, В. Тунимaнова, В. Ветловской, И. Волгина, а также издающееся Академией наук СССР Полное акaдемическое собрание сочинений Достоевского и его «спутники» — сборники  «Достоевский. Материалы и исследования».

В Ноттингемском университете есть кaфедра и факультет славистики. Их создaтелeм явился автор ряда монографий по истории  русской литературы XIX  века  Я.Лаврин.  В настоящее время кафедру славистики  в Ноттингеме     возглавляет М. Джонс, автор талантливой монографии о­ Достоевском. Вместе с профессором  Р. Писом (Бристоль) он подготовил нынешний симпозиум.                   

На VI симпозиуме МОД было заслушано 67 докладов и сообщений, посвященных творчеству Достоевского 1870—1881 годов. В них был поднят широкий круг вопросов: исторический контекст творчествa, процесс создания    художественных  произведений,  литературные образы, философские идeи,  язык и стиль, публицистика  писателя. Ряд интересных  и  содержательных  докладов был посвящен проблемaм «Достоевский и  современный теaтр» и «Роль наследия Достоевского в культурной  жизни XX  века».

В симпозиуме приняли участиe как широко известные ученые, так и молодые исследователи. Прения нередко носили острый характер, но это не нарушало атмосферу творчества и взаимопонимaния.  Мудрый призыв Достоевского к дружбе и сотрудничеству народов, к защите природы и человечества oт сил, толкающих нa путь уничтожения земной цивилизации,  воплощенный в «Братьях Карамазовых», был специально рассмотрен в докладе Г. М. Фридлендeрa. Новые аспекты изучения поздних произведений Достоевского и его мировой славы были освещены в докладaх М. Кадо, Ж. Кaтто (оба — Фрaнция). М. Джонса, Р. Писа (Англия), Т. Киносита (Япония), Н. Кирaй, Л. Силарл (ВНР), М. Вегнерa (ГДР), А. Лaзaри и А. Разни (ПНР), Р. Л. Джексона. Р. Белнапа, У. Тодда, Ф. Силбояриса (США), С. Пенчичa и М. Йовaновичa (СФРЮ), А. Гедройцa, С. Андерсон (Бельгия) и др.

По предложению А. Сказа (Любляна, СФРЮ) следующий (VII) симпозиум  общества решено провести в Любляне в 1989 году. Основная тема будущего симпозиумa —«Достоевский и культура XX  века», М. Кaдо, Р. Нойхойзер, Н. Нaтова и другие члены исполнительного комитета МОД подчеркнули,  что они    не мыслят дальнейшей  работы общества без постоянного расширения  его сотрудничества с учеными СССР.         

 

 

210

Announcements

On 20-21-22 February 11987 a CONFERENCE ON RUSSIAN LITERATURE AND PSYCHOANALYSIS will be held at the University of California in Davis. For more information, write to: Daniel Rancour-Laferriere, Russian Department, University of California, Davis, CA. 95616.

The Seventh International Dostoevsky Symposium will take place in August 1989 in Ljubljana. Further information will be provided in Dostoevsky Studies, no. 8.
 

213



ПИСЬМО В РЕДАКЦИЮ

Уважаемая профессор Госшило,
 

Если бы Ваша рецензия на мою книгу о поэтике цитат в Братьях Карамазовых была послана в менее специализированное и авто­ритетное издание, чем Dostoevsky Studies, я, скорее всего, не поддалась бы соблазну русских авторов прошлого века писать "критику критики". Но в данном случае считаю это нужным, т.к. опасаюсь, что Ваше безапелляционное и неаргументированное неприятие главных принципов моего теоретического подхода к проблеме может создать и у профессионально подготовленных читателей искаженное представление о всей работе.
 

Ваши неодобрительные, но ничем не аргументированные замечания относятся к моему сознательно выбранному и последовательно осуществленному намерению исследовать и развить ряд мало изученных аспектов Бахтинской теории художественного высказывания. - За сознательное осуществление намерений действительно осуждают, - но в гражданских судах, а не в академических кругах. "В мире книг" выполнение авторских намерений принято оценивать положительно.
 

В сфере структурно-типологических исследований идеи Бахтина помогают установить диалогические отношения между различными, несоприродными эстетика-философскими концепциями и позволяют осуществлять их адекватных перевод в единую, внутренне не­противоречивую систему. Как в литературном переводе гомогенность поэтического словаря, так в данном случае единство научной терминологии - обязательное условие, обеспечивающее возможность этой операции. Цель теоретической главы в моей книге - осуществить не столько "синтез", сколько перевод двух внутренне трёхсоставных теорий (художественное отражение Тарановского) в бинарную систему Бахтина: авторитарное - внутренне убедительное высказывание. Поскольку для своей работы, а не только для "пятидесяти с чем-то страниц", как Вы отмечаете, я выбрала единый методологический подход, я естественно смогла воспользоваться единой терминологией. Ваше язвительное замечание, что моя книга производит впечатление "Бахтинали", говорит не столько о Вашем остроумии, сколько о нежелании понять принципы предложенного теоретического под­хода и умении разобраться в них.

  Невнимание к теме моей работы и её общей теории лишь подтверждается Вашими частными замечаниями (стр. 192). Указание на внутреннюю связь идей Ивана Карамазова и Ставрогина имеет отношение к проблеме сквозных мотивов и "блуждающих образов" в творчестве Достоевского, но цитатно в тексте не проявляется. Вопросы о сквозных мотивах и фольклорных источниках творчества Достоевского изучались Бемом, Долининым, Комаровичем, Ветловской, на труды которых я неоднократно ссылалась в работе. Касаясь Вашего обвинения меня в допущенных натяжках — напо-

 

214



минает ли карамаэовский чёрт репортера провинциальной газеты — я вынуждена адресовать Вас к тексту романа, т. 15, стр. 76, где сам чёрт рассказывает анекдот о том, как его заметку не приняли в редакции из боязни "повредить направлению" издания.

В заключение: справедливы, заслужены и полезны для меня Ваши указания относительно моего несвободного владения английским языком. Если моя книга будет переиздана, Ваши замечания касательно стиля, пунктуации и типографского оформления (стр. 192) будут учтены.

 С уважением

 Нина Перлина, Университет Рутгерс.

 

215

Report

Nadine Natov, Executive Secretary of IDS

The Sixth International Dostoevsky Symposium, sponsored by the International Dostoevsky Society, was held at Nightingale Hall at the University of Nottingham, England, August 9-16 1986.

The Symposium was organized by Professor Malcolm V. Jones of the University of Nottingham, who was assisted by his colleagues Professors Cynthia Marsh and James Muckle and by Professors Anthony Briggs, University of Bristol, William Leatherbarrow, University of Sheffield, and Nadine Natov, The George Washington University, USA, The preparation of the Program was in the hands of Professor Richard Peace, University of Bristol, who was assisted by Professors Malcolm V. Jones, Head of the Organizing Committee, Michel Cadot, President of the IDS, Sorbonne, Paris, and Robert Louis Jackson, former IDS President, Yale University, USA.

With the Sixth Symposium the International Dostoevsky Society marked its fifteenth anniversary. It was founded in September of 1971 in Bad Ems, Germany, by a group of Dostoevsky scholars, among them Professors Robert Louis Jackson, Rudolf Neuhäuser, Nadine Natov, Reinhard Lauth, Dominique Arban, Jan van der Eng, Nils Åke Nilsson, Dmitry Grishin and Alexis Guédroitz. Nils Åke Nilsson, Professor of Stockholm University, was elected the first President of the IDS. Robert Louis Jackson (Yale University), Reinhard Lauth (University of Munich), Dmitry Grishin (Melbourne University), and Mihai Novicov (University of Bucharest) were elected Vice-Presidents. Nadine Natov was elected Executive Secretary, and Rudolf Neuhäuser (then University of Western Ontario, Canada) was elected Editor of the Bulletin of the IDS. Due to the efforts of the Executive Board, the Society succeeded to unite many Dostoevsky scholars throughout the world. Every three years IDS organises an international symposium: IDS members had the opportunity to meet and discuss the results of their research in St. Wolfgang, Austria, in Rungstedgaard, Denmark, in Bergamo, Italy, and in Cerisy-la-Salle, France. In Cerisy, at the Fifth International Dostoevsky Symposium, two internationally known scholars - Professors René Wellek (Yale) and Georgii M. Fridlender (Leningrad) were elected Honorary Presidents of the IDS. Professor Wellek, an active participant of almost all the previous Symposia, was prevented from coming to Nottingham due to his health condition. Professor Georgii Fridlender presented a paper and participated actively in the discussion of the papers read in Nottingham.

The Sixth Symposium was inaugurated on August 9th, 1986, by

216

Professor Michel Cadot, President of the IDS, and Professor Malcolm V. Jones, Vice President of the IDS and head of the Organizing Committee. Scholars who have made the study of Dostoevsky's works and of the intellectual currents of his time one of their main fields of research came to Nottingham from 21 countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Federal Republic of Germany, German Democratic Republic, Great Britain, Hungary, India, Italy, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, South Africa, Sweden, USA, USSR, and Yugoslavia. Together with many "veterans" - old members of the IDS, who actively participated in the previous five Symposia, scholars from India and Poland were this time among the speakers.

The main topic of the Sixth Dostoevsky Symposium was the discussion of Dostoevsky's works written during the last period of his life: the novels Raw Youth, The Brothers Karamazov, and The Diary of a Writer. Sixty one papers presented at the Symposium were grouped around six major themes: 1. The Historical context of Dostoevsky's works; 2. Philosophical Ideas; 3. Language and Style; 4. The Creative Process and Literary Characters; 5. Structure and Genre, and 6. Dostoevsky as a Publicist. The papers were read and the discussion was conducted in the four languages, accepted by the IDS, namely in English, Russian, French, and German. Each participant received a final program and a brochure with the resumes of the papers in two languages, one of them Russian or English.

Several organisatorial problems were discussed at the meetings of the Executive Board, such as the proposed place for the next Symposium, and changes in the Executive Board and the representatives of Dostoevsky scholars in various countries. The proposals of the Executive Board were offered for discussion and approval to the General Assembly which took place on August 13th, 1986. Two countries - Yugoslavia and Norway - proposed to shelter the seventh Symposium in 1989. Yugoslav scholars had already proposed to hold a Dostoevsky Symposium in Ljubljana. This proposal had been transmitted to the Fifth Symposium at Cerisy. In early August 1986, the proposed places in Yugoslavia were visited by Professors Alexander Skaza, Rudolf Neuhäuser, and Nadine Natov, and, eventually, Ljubljana was proposed as the site for the Seventh Dostoevsky Symposium. The General Assembly approved the choice of Ljubljana as the place of the next Symposium in August 1989. The main topic of the Seventh Symposium will be "F. M. Dostoevsky in the Twentieth Century."

The Program Committee of the Seventh Symposium will consist of Professors Michel Cadot, Nadine Natov (coordinator), Rudolf Neuhäuser, and Richard Peace. An Organizing Committee is being formed which will include Professors Alexander Skaza, Rudolf Neuhäuser, and Ivan Verč. It was resolved to reduce the number of papers to 40-45, and to organize two discussion sessions, one of them to be devoted to the topic "Dostoevsky and Yugoslav Literatures."

217

Professor Alexis Guédroitz informed the General Assembly, in the name of the Nominating Committee and the Executive Board that the President of the IDS, Professor Michel Cadot had accepted the nomination for a second term; the Vice Presidents Professors Malcolm V. Jones, Gyula Király, Geir Kjetsaa and Victor Terras also accepted the nomination for a second term. Professor Nina Kaucisvili, who served two three-year terms as Vice President was replaced by Professor Rudolf Neuhäuser. The Executive Secretary Nadine Natov and the Editor of Dostoevsky Studies Rudolf Neuhäuser also agreed to continue in their positions. The General Assembly approved of these changes.

It was proposed and supported by the General Assembly to invite Academician Dmitry S. Likhachev as Honorary President of the IDS. Until the time of this report the answer was not yet received by the Executive Secretary. It was resolved to reduce the number of the regional coordinators (former national representatives) for the sake of a more effective mailing and exchange of informations. It was proposed and supported to introduce into the IDS Honorary Board two outstanding Dostoevsky scholar Dominique Arban (Paris) and Jan van der Eng (Amsterdam), founding members of the IDS and participants of the IDS Symposia.

At the General Assembly meeting, Professor Michel Cadot remembered those outstanding scholars who participated at various IDS Symposia, but are no longer with us. The audience honored the memory of their late colleagues Gleb P. Struve, Sigurd Fasting, Jan van Meyer, Father Georgii Florovsky, Academician Mikhail B. Khrapchenko, Dmitry Čiževsky and Dmitry Grishin.

At the final banquet on August 15th, members of the Executive Board expressed their profound gratitude to Professor Malcolm Jones and to his colleagues for the very successful organization of the Symposium and a quiet, friendly atmosphere during the Symposium.

One afternoon was dedicated to an excursion. The participants had the choice between two places : to visit Stratford on Avon, and attend a performance of Romeo and Juliet at the Royal Memorial Theatre, or to visit Newstead Abbey, Eastwood and D. H. Lawrence's home country. Newstead is the ancestral home and birthplace of Lord Byron; Eastwood is the birthplace of D. H. Lawrence, who was once a student at Nottingham University College.

The organizers of the Nottingham Symposium, Professor Malcolm V. Jones, Dr. Cynthia Marsh, and Dr. James Muckle should be specially commended for an excellent exhibition in Nightingale Hall of books and articles written by the participants in the Symposium. The participants could obtain some of these publications. Several copies of the two last issues of Dostoevsky Studies were on display. A selection of papers from the Seventh Symposium will be published in issues seven and eight of Dostoevsky Studies.

University of Toronto